Ohio Supreme Court declines to reconsider Mackenzie Shirilla's appeal

The state's high court has once again rejected a motion from convicted killer Mackenzie Shirilla that would have reopened her case.

4 across the spectrum. Choose a side on the bar to jump to it.

National story. 5 articles from 4 sources. Updated Sep 2, 2026.

How each side is putting it

Left

1 source
Cleveland Plain DealerLean Left· Sep 2, 2026

Ohio Supreme Court rejects Mackenzie Shirilla’s bid to revive her latest appeal

Center

2 sources
Court TVCenter· Sep 2, 2026

Ohio Supreme Court refuses to consider Mackenzie Shirilla appeal filed late

Ran by 2 outlets· WKBN Youngstown, FOX 8 Cleveland
WKBN YoungstownCenter· Sep 2, 2026

Ohio Supreme Court declines to reconsider Mackenzie Shirilla's appeal

FOX 8 ClevelandCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Ohio Supreme Court declines to reconsider Mackenzie Shirilla's appeal

Right

1 source
Fox NewsRight· Sep 2, 2026

Ohio Supreme Court denies Mackenzie Shirilla's latest appeal bid in double murder case