Chocolate eyeball candy sold at Marshalls, TJ Maxx recalled

A chocolate eyeball candy sold at major retailers has been recalled in multiple states because it contains an undeclared ingredient that could trigger serious allergic reactions in some people.

18 across the spectrum. Choose a side on the bar to jump to it.

National story. 31 articles from 18 sources. Updated Sep 3, 2026.

How each side is putting it

Left

4 sources
Fast CompanyLean Left· Sep 3, 2026

Halloween candy scare: FDA warns people to ‘destroy’ chocolate sold at 4 major retail chains in 13 states over life-threatening risk

Ran by 5 outlets across the spectrum· Cleveland Plain Dealer, NJ.com / Star-Ledger
Cleveland Plain DealerLean Left· Sep 2, 2026

Chocolate sold in 13 states recalled for potentially ‘life-threatening’ ingredient

NJ.com / Star-LedgerLean Left· Sep 2, 2026

Chocolate sold in 13 states recalled for potentially ‘life-threatening’ ingredient

QuartzLean Left· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween chocolate eyeballs sold at TJ Maxx and Marshalls recalled over hidden milk allergen

Center

11 sources
CBS NewsCenter· Sep 3, 2026

Chocolate eyeball candy sold at Marshalls, TJ Maxx recalled

The OregonianCenter· Sep 2, 2026· ran in 5 outlets

Chocolate sold in 13 states recalled for potentially ‘life-threatening’ ingredient

UPICenter· Sep 1, 2026

FDA: Halloween chocolate eyeballs recalled

Ran by 14 outlets· WPRI Providence, DC News Now, +12 more
WPRI ProvidenceCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

DC News NowCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

The HillCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

WGN ChicagoCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

WANE Fort WayneCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

WCBD News 2Center· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

Mycham Plain ValleyCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

KTSM 9 NewsCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

WWLP SpringfieldCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

WRBL ColumbusCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

WHNTCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

FOX 40 SacramentoCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

CW 39 HoustonCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

Phl17Center· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled

FOX8 WGHPCenter· Sep 1, 2026

Halloween candy sold in 13 states, including North Carolina, recalled

Right

3 sources
New York PostLean Right· Sep 3, 2026

Popular Halloween candy recalled in California over allergen

Ran by 5 outlets across the spectrum· AL.com, MLive
AL.comLean Right· Sep 2, 2026

Chocolate sold in 13 states recalled for potentially ‘life-threatening’ ingredient

MLiveLean Right· Sep 2, 2026

Chocolate sold in 13 states recalled for potentially ‘life-threatening’ ingredient

The story so far

2 developments
  1. Aug 31Halloween candy sold in 13 states recalled
  2. Sep 3Popular Halloween candy recalled in California over allergen

Who covered each development

No new developments

Quiet for 44 days

Last development · Sep 3 — Popular Halloween candy recalled in California over allergen